Digging the Back Bins: Bluegrass

April 13, 2021

Digging the Back Bins: Bluegrass

Deep Cut sits down with Amy Reitnouer Jacobs, Co-Founder and Executive Director of the Bluegrass Situation (BGS) to talk about bluegrass: what it is, what it isn’t, what to look for on wax, and the new BGS podcast Toy Heart , with Tom Power.

The new Podcast Toy Heart with Tom Power explores the history of bluegrass through interviews with the people who built the genre. Including Alice Gerard (pictured).

The new Podcast Toy Heart with Tom Power explores the history of bluegrass through interviews with the people who built the genre. Including Alice Gerard (pictured).

One of the joys of record collecting is diving into a dusty bin and finding an unknown record for $5 that then becomes a favorite. You stand a better chance of having this experience in some genres because they are overrepresented in used record bins and underappreciated by buyers. We’ve talked about Jazz and Country music. This time, we sat down with Amy Reitnouer Jacobs, Co-Founder and Executive Director of the Bluegrass Situation, to learn about bluegrass. With the recent launch of the podcast Toy Heart with Tom Power, it has never been a better time to find a way in.

So what is Bluegrass?

Canva - Man Holding Banjo Standing Beside Wall.jpg

If you aren’t that familiar, a quick orientation: think banjos. Think of the O Brother Where Art Thou Soundtrack.  Still nothing? Ok, if country music is a river, bluegrass is a fork, one that runs over in the direction of folk in parts. Bill Monroe, the inventor of bluegrass toured as a country act. The genre got its name from his band, the Blue Grass Boys, as more musicians started to imitate Monroe’s sound. 

What makes it different from Country? 

There are a few things. “To get technical,” says Jacobs, “it’s a combination of six main instruments [banjo, guitar, fiddle, mandolin, upright bass, dobro], with certain song structures, and a lot of times you have a vocal tone called the ‘high-lonesome’ sound.” Traditional bluegrass is also distinctive in its lightning-fast, picked-out instrumentation. You will hear banjo, mandolin, fiddle and guitar players race up and down their fret-boards, dancing out arpeggios all at the same time. 

What’s so special about this Bluegrass anyway?

Banjo. Fiddle. Mandolin. Beard. Hats. Alright, you folks are good to go…

Banjo. Fiddle. Mandolin. Beard. Hats. Alright, you folks are good to go…

You could marvel at the technical chops. Or the beautiful cacophony of it. With so many melodies and countermelodies all going on at once, it should sound like a room of toddlers bashing toy pianos. Instead it sounds like the London Philharmonic, if you replaced their instruments with plywood and chicken wire. And maybe it’s us, but we think there are few genres that evoke a sense of place more strongly than bluegrass (we’d say a crisp blue fall day in wooded mountains, with fire smoke the air).

Not convinced? The barriers to entry here are low, so we think you should give it a shot. “You can find some really good vintage records for pretty cheap, because people just don’t know what they're looking for,” says Jacobs.

Ok, what should I be looking for?

We’re so glad you asked. 

First Generation Bluegrass artists Jim and Jesse

First Generation Bluegrass artists Jim and Jesse

Traditional Bluegrass: For the original sounds that defined the genre, seek out records by the first generation of Bluegrass artists like Bill Monroe himself, Flatt and Scruggs, Jim and Jesse, the Osborne Brothers, or the Stanley Brothers

JD Crowe

JD Crowe

Folk -Tinged Bluegrass: The second generation of bluegrass players In the 1970s incorporated more folk into the sound. Artists like Tony Rice borrowed songs and styles from contemporary music, while Hazel Dickens and Alice Gerrard adopted a stripped-down sound a la the Anthology of American Folk Music. Look for records by JD Crowe, Doc Watson, Ricky Skaggs and Alison Krauss. (Krauss actually came up later -1989- than the others mentioned here. Skaggs can be confusing for those unfamiliar with bluegrass because, while he’s a bluegrass legend, he also spent the 1980s as a chart-topping mainstream country artist.)  

Rhiannon Giddens. Photo by Schorle

Rhiannon Giddens. Photo by Schorle

Modern Bluegrass: Bluegrass is still a thriving genre with artists that are celebrating its traditions and expanding its boundaries. “You are seeing a lot of folks in the genre who are not falling into a stereotype and are exploring its true history,” says Jacobs. “Rhiannon Giddens is a great example. She started in the Carolina Chocolate Drops but has gone on to have her own career that has not been defined by genres, and can still do a record that pulls as much from Irish tradition or Middle Eastern tradition as it does from Appalachian banjo playing. It’s rewarding and innovative and it looks at an un-white-washed version of the history of this music.”

Che Apalache is another artist Jabobs points to as exemplifying the expansion and experimentation in Bluegrass. “[Fiddler/vocalist Joe Troop] writes stuff with an Appalachian bluegrass backbone that is put through the filter of Argintinian musicians, and then he will sing in Japanese. It is just incredible stuff.”

Other artists to look out for: Billy Strings, Molly Tuttle, Amethyst Kiah, and the many projects of virtuoso mandolinist Christ Thile, including Nickel Creek, the Punch Brothers, and many others. 

Billy Strings 2017 release Turmoil & Tinfoil on vinyl

Billy Strings 2017 release Turmoil & Tinfoil on vinyl

What if I want to dig deeper?

The CBC’s Tom Power, host of the Bluegrass Situation’s Toy Heart Podcast

The CBC’s Tom Power, host of the Bluegrass Situation’s Toy Heart Podcast

Did we mention there was a podcast? Toy Heart features in-depth interviews with some of the greats of the first and second generations of Bluegrass, like Ricky Skaggs and Del McCoury. It is hosted by Tom Power, host of the CBC’s q. “It’s turned into such a beautiful series,” gushes Jacobs. “I’ve been doing this website for almost 9 years. You think you’ve heard all the stories. But multiple times in this series, Tom has gotten the response: ‘I don’t think I’ve ever told that story’ or ‘I don’t even think my kids know that story.’ It is just a testament to how great Tom is an interviewer.” New episodes will be dropping every other week through June 11. Check it out now. 

The wider Bluegrass Situation is also a fantastic place to start. It features reviews, profiles, and interviews with people making things happen in Bluegrass. They recently launched a Podcast network which includes not just Toy Heart, but others like The Breakdown, and The Show on the Road. They have a Spotify channel with huge range of playlists, a YouTube channel packed with live performances, and a lot more.

Lastly, we’ll mention that BGS is launching a weekly webcast variety show, the Whisky Sour Happy Hour, to help us all pass the time while we are stuck indoors for the foreseeable future. Hosted by THE Ed Helms, it will feature music, interviews, and comedy. Many of the bluegrass artists we’ve already mentioned are set to appear, but also, Yola, who isn’t bluegrass, but is amazing. Definitely check her out. Proceeds will benefit the MusiCares Coivd-19 Relief Fund. The first episode airs Wednesday, April 22 at 8pm Eastern/ 7pm Central/ 5pm Pacific.


There you have it.

Bluegrass: another rich vein for vinyl enthusiasts to mine. Happy digging.

Nine Essential Bluegrass Albums

Want to show up to all of this prepared? Bluegrass Situation Co-Founder Amy Jacobs’s offers nine albums that define the genre for her. 

Flatt and Scruggs Carnegie Hall.jpg

Flatt and Scruggs - Flatt and Scruggs at Carnegie Hall Banjoist Earl Scruggs and Guitarist Lester Flatt earned the undying enmity of their former boss Bill Monroe when they broke off from his Blue Grass Boys to become legends of Bluegrass in their own right. “It is a seminal record for the genre, and it really holds up,” says Jacobs. “And it sounds great on vinyl.

Elementary Doctor Watson.jpg

Doc Watson - Elementary Doctor Watson

Doc Watson “represents more of the old time and Appalachian tradition,” says Jacobs. “He really defined a certain guitar style that is really prevalent today, but nobody could pick like Doc. I see this one at record stores a lot.”

JD Crowe and the New South.jpg

JD Crowe & The New South - JD Crowe & The New South (also known as 0044 after its Rounder Records catalogue number). This record is often cited (including by Tom Power in the Toy Heart episode with Ricky Skaggs) as an album that changed the sound and direction of Bluegrass. “We have a really deep cut oral history of this record on the [Bluegrass Situation] website,” notes Jacobs.

John Hartford Aereo Plane.jpg

John Hartford - Aereo-Plain

“John Hartford was part of this new folk tradition in bluegrass,” says Jacobs. “He is an amazing all-around artist. Aereo-Plain for me is just one of the best.”

Tony Rice.jpg

The Tony Rice Unit - Manzanita

Guitarist Tony Rice has played on many of the best Bluegrass albums, including his own. Jacobs: “Tony Rice is so revered in the community that it’s just hard not to include this one on any list.”

Strength in Numbers - The Telluride Sessions

This Bluegrass supergroup featured Bela Fleck, Mark O’Connor, Sam Bush, Jerry Douglas, and Edger Meyer, who were all bluegrass stars in their own right. “Man is this an incredible record!” gushes Jacobs. “Those guys all play the Telluride Bluegrass Festival every year. I think it is better than Christmas that week.”

Noam Pikelny.jpg

Noam Pikelny - Noam Pikelny Plays Kenny Baker Plays Bill Monroe

Jacobs:“Noam is just really funny, but also just one of the best banjo players in the world today. There’s a history to this one. Bill Monroe did a record, and this very famous fiddle player named Kenny Baker re-did the record and re-interpreted mandoline led songs as fiddle tunes. Noam then a couple of years ago re-interpreted it again. So you have these three generations of the genre re-interpreted multiple times over. And it’s just a beautiful record. And it’s got a great album cover.”


Nickel Creek - Why Should the Fire Die

Jacobs: “This is the first [bluegrass] band that I saw that really changed my life. They were the entry point for a lot of folks in my generation. And it was a big awakening of what traditional music could be. My personal favorite of theirs. You could listen to anything from their catalog, and they have each gone on to do amazing things, but I come back to this record a lot.”

Goat Rodeo Sessions.jpg

Yo-Yo Ma, Stuart Duncan, Edgar Meyer, Chris Thile - The Goat Rodeo Sessions This is another supergroup featuring, yes that Yo-Yo Ma, as well as some of the top bluegrass tallents in Duncan, Meyer, and Thile. Jacobs:  “I would put this in my top 10 records ever. It represents the pushing of the boundaries and the blurring of the lines. Chris Thile has really moved mandoline playing forward. He has moved mountain music into a really revered form. His collaborations have been wide ranging and have pushed the genre in different ways. This is, I think the best example of that. And it’s a beautiful record.” A second installment drops on May 1.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in Blog: Deep Cuts

20 Album Covers Perfect For Displaying On The Wall
20 Album Covers Perfect For Displaying On The Wall

January 24, 2024

When it comes to displaying on your wall, some record artwork really stands out. Here are 20 of our favorites. Side note, it wouldn't be on this list if we didn't also love the music. So just consider that a given.

View full article →

Gift guide for the vinyl person in your life with a photo featuring a Deep Cut tabletop record stand
Our 2023 Vinyl Lovers Gift Guide

November 30, 2023

We want you to crush this holiday. We want each of your gift recipients to shed a single tear that catches the glint of candle light just as a light snow begins to fall on the handbell choir that has gathered to serenade the class of orphans that has come to the town square to pick out a kitten from an miracle litter at the humane society. And we want them to say ‘This [sob] is what Christmas means to me.” And if the gifts in your own stocking would earn the side-eye from the Goodwill donations rep, we’d like you to have some ideas for yourself as well.

View full article →

The Right System for Your Vinyl: Mixing & Matching Modern and Vintage
The Right System for Your Vinyl: Mixing & Matching Modern and Vintage

August 24, 2023

Modern? Vintage? Both? What's the answer?? Well, the hybrid system just might be the best. It allows you to mix and match components until you find ones that are just right. Solid components can last the rest of your life (and longer). Flexibility on provenance can enable you to find deals. Ultimately, you can end up with a system that fits you like your favorite pair of jeans. But how? And with which of what?

View full article →